Capitalism in terminal decline: the compelling empirical data trends
➤ The aggregate ‘world’ rate of profit has trended towards zero, from an estimated average of 43% in the 1870s to 11% in the 2010s.
➤ Interest rates (interest being a form of profit) over (at least) the past seven centuries have also trended towards zero, where short-term baseline rates have been stuck for most of the period since 2009 — record lows in both the US and UK, the traditional capitalist superpowers — but ending recessions, which tend to start from a lower baseline rate each time, requires, on average, a 6% cut to the baseline rate.
➤ Prices have also closed in on zero — at exponential pace as, amid accelerating innovation, productive output tends to double absolutely every 25 years. X number of commodities made in half as much time as before will, all else being equal, cost half as much.
➤ The average lifespan of the richest private corporations is continually contracting, falling to below 20 years in the 2010s.
➤ Whereas the capitalist class is a relatively dwindling minority, the global working class since the 1950s has been growing exponentially.
➤ Fossil fuels and energy are becoming too expensive to produce profitably.
➤ To economise production and offset falling profitability, capital accumulation is increasingly dependent on central planning within private enterprise and mergers between private enterprise. A ‘final merger’, a therefore public monopoly, enabling central planning of the economy as a whole — and social accumulation — is consequently becoming an economic necessity for the first time.
Since the evolution of production from mechanisation to automation is abolishing capital’s veiled theft/exploitation of commodity-producing labour’s labour time — the source of (exchange) value and profit — capitalism is sooner or later bound to spiral into crises of hyperinflation and hyperdeflation, record-high unemployment and collapsing productivity.
This historical process is not reversible: innovation is inherent to the nonstop nature of evolution; while capital accumulation itself demands innovation, absolutely rising productivity and cheaper-to-produce commodities in order to offset falling profitability initiated by previous expansions in production that devalue the average commodity.
Socialism, whereby private enterprise (producing commodified utilities) owned by a relative few capitalists is turned into social enterprise (producing decommodified utilities) owned by the public is therefore becoming an economic necessity for the first time.
With the increasing speed, cheapness and decentralisation of production (as with smartphones and laptops, for example) increasingly enabling abundant material wealth for all, ‘lower’ ‘state socialism’ will then evolve into ‘higher’ ‘stateless’ communism.
➤ The average global rate of profit is trending historically towards zero, having fallen from an estimated 43% in the 1870s to 17% in the 2000s and 11% in the 2010s.
➤ GDP growth rates in ‘high income countries’ are trending towards and already closing in on zero, having averaged around 6% in the 1960s and below 2% since 2000.
➤ The post-recession recovery from the 2007–09 Global Financial Crisis (GFC) — based on unsustainable debt and a temporary shale gas revolution that peaked in 2019 — has been the weakest, relatively, since WWII.
Whereas US GDP grew by 43% over the first 39 quarters of the 1991–2001 expansion, in the first 39 quarters of the expansion up to March 2019, it grew by only 22%. At that rate, the latter would have had to continue for another six years to equal the aggregate growth of 1991–2001, and nine more to match the the 54% recorded in 1961–69.
➤ The rate of productivity growth has trended downwards over the past seven decades to near-zero.
➤ Between 1964 and 2014, the average lifespan of S&P 500 companies shrank from around 60 to 18 years.
➤ From 1977 to 2013, startups as a share of all US firms fell from 16.5% to 8%, a decline pervasive across states and sectors.
➤ Of the roughly 750 currencies that have existed since 1700, only around 20% remain.
➤ British pound sterling has lost more than 99.5% of its purchasing power since its adoption as official currency in 1694.
The US dollar in 2018 had lost more than 96% of its purchasing power since 1913, having barely changed in the previous 140 years when the rate of the economy’s growth (relative to its size) was much higher.
The vast amount of that figure, 91%, ensued after 1949, when the US supplanted Britain as the world’s dominant imperialist superpower.
The figure since 1970 is 85% (93.5% for Britain), around the time of the first major post-WWII recession and the start of the digital/computing/automation revolution.
Although the rate of innovation tends to slow down as the rate of profit falls, the pace of innovation tends to accelerate absolutely. Computing power tends to double every 18–24 months (Moore’s Law) and total production tends to double every 25 years, devaluing commodities as much less labour time is contained in each commodity, thereby also devaluing the money-commodity.
➤ Production costs and consumer commodity prices have therefore trended secularly/historically towards zero.
For example, whereas the world’s fastest supercomputer in 1975 was worth $5m ($32m in 2013’s money), the price of an iPhone 4 released in 2010 with the equivalent performance was $400.
Aerospace companies producing propulsion systems in 2010 for $24m in 24 months were by 2018 3-D printing their engines for $2,000 in two weeks.
One gigabyte of data storage fell from $193,000 in 1980 to just $0.03 in 2014.
While sequencing the first human genome took 13 years and in 2001 cost $100 billion, the cost had fallen to below $1,000 by 2016 and now takes about 24 hours.
In 2000, the cost of producing one kilogram of protein through precision fermentation cost $1 million, but in 2020 the cost had fallen to around $100.
As soon as a company like Nestle starts buying its milk this way (it is already investigating viability) — as it must to rewiden its own profit margins — the conventional farming industry will become uncompetitive and unprofitable.
➤ With deposits becoming shallower and deeper and extraction more capital-intensive (dependent on machinery relative to labour), the Energy Return on Investment (EROI) on fossil fuel has fallen from above 100:1 (a return of 100 units of energy for every 1 invested) in 1930 to around 3–6:1 in 2019.
The labour intensity (including the labour needed to produce capital-intensive extraction machinery) of fossil fuel production and its non-renewability (constantly reproducing the industry’s demand for labour) has been vital to capitalism’s overall profitability.
The ‘tight/shale oil revolution’ breathed some life into the oil industry in the 2010s but peaked in 2019.
The value of Saudi Arabia’s state assets, mainly in oil, is predicted to fall from $900bn to minus-$2trn around 2030.
In 2015, the total debt of the oil and gas sector globally stood at roughly $2.5 trillion, 250% higher than at the end of 2006.
The fossil fuel industry only remains ‘profitable’ because of its parasitic dependence on debt/public subsidies — no bottomless pit — of $16bn a day and artificial cuts to production that normally raise consumer prices by 70–80%.)
➤ Just as the number of slaves in the US declined as a percentage of the population (from approx. 25% in 1790 to 16% in 1860) before slavery ended; manufacturing workers declined as a percentage of the US workforce from 26.4% in 1970 to 8% in 2018.
Science has usurped manufacturing as the mother of production and the working class is now largely based in services instead of physical commodity production, even in South America and Sub-Saharan Africa.
Whereas the capitalist class is a relatively dwindling minority of the world population, the working class (people who’s income depends on waged employment) has grown exponentially (outmoding capitalist ‘democracy’ — which makes standing for election prohibitively expensive and excludes the working class from participating in policy-making — and, along with new technological capacities (debating and voting online), precipitating participatory socialist democracy).
➤ Trade restrictions have been hitting record levels since 2015, before Brexit and the presidency of Donald Trump.
➤ The medium real revenue growth of ‘FAANG’ stocks — Facebook, Amazon, Apple, Netflix and Google, the five best-performing American technology companies of the 2010s, comprising about 20% of the value of the S&P 500— turned negative in 2022 for the first time.
➤ 2022 was the worst year for stocks and bonds combined since 1871. Long-term US government bonds staged the biggest drop since 1788. The classic investor blend of bonds and equities put in the worst performance since 1932.
At its lowest point in 2022, the S&P 500 index in the US had shed $11trn in market capitalisation, similar to the entire annual economic output of Germany, Japan and Canada combined.
➤ Almost half, 43%, of around 9,000 commercial banks in the US disappeared between 2000 and the end of 2017 (already down from 14,000 in 1986 and 30,000 in 1921).
Losses on the banking industry’s investment securities totalled $690bn in the third quarter (Q3) of 2022 — compared to less than $100bn in 2008 at the height of the GFC.
Total banking assets of $23.6trn were matched by total liabilities (money owed) of $23.6trn; but once the devaluations of face value investments as a result of rising interest rates/borrowing costs are taken into account (along with several other factors) the US banking industry as a whole was a conservatively estimated — not including exposure to hidden derivatives and cryptocurrency — $400bn short of solvency.
➤ A third ‘one-in-100-year’ financial bubble in three decades — the first three to surpass the bubble preceding the 1929 Wall Street Crash — engulfing the world economy has been labelled ‘the everything bubble’ (the previous two being the 2000–01 dot com bubble and the 2007–09 housing bubble) since it now encompasses every asset/debt class for the first time.
Official US national debt-to-GDP — driven by private sector debt heaped onto the backs of the public — hit an all-time high of 137.2% in 2021. The record high aggregate global debt is unsustainable since the tax base needed to repay it is shrinking in relative terms.
➤ To bail out private banks and private corporations (by purchasing their debt, spending the money into existence), the balance sheet of the Federal Reserve, the US central bank, rose from $900bn in September 2008, during the GFC, to $9 trillion (trn) in 2020 — an unprecedented 10-fold increase.
➤ The US’s M1 money supply (very liquid monies such as cash and traveller’s checks) rose from $1.6trn in May 2009, to $4trn in February 2020, to $16.5trn in June 2020; and $20.7trn in March 2020.
The broader M2 supply (M1 plus less liquid monies such as savings and money market funds) went from $8.4trn in June 2009 to $15.3trn in February 2020 and $22trn in April 2022.
That meant 80.7% of all M1 ever put into circulation was ‘printed’ (electronically) in just 23 months; 69.5% for M2 in 26 months.
For comparison, the total the US spent on its wars on Afghanistan, Iraq, Syria and Pakistan from 2001 to 2020 cost cost $6.4trn.
➤ Lifting the US economy out of recession has required on average since 1958 a baseline interest rate cut of 6% (in order to cheapen capital to incentivise lending and borrowing); but since the (worst ever) stock market crash in March 2020, rates were already near zero, having been cut after March 2020 from 0.75% in the UK and 1.75% in the US.
Neither country had ever gone down to 0% before 2009.
➤ The central bank cannot print money indefinitely as there is only so much banking and corporate debt to purchase and increasing demand relative to supply stimulates inflation and thus business costs that eat into profit margins.
As ‘smaller’ or poorer banks and corporations go bust or default on their debts to the central bank, the central bank balance sheet (and thus the money supply) naturally falls and so interest rates inversely rise — making new debt needed to pay off the interest on old debt more expensive, including for governments and central banks.
In 2023 the Congressional Budget Office projected that US government interest costs would grow nearly threefold from $331bn in 2021 (2% of GDP) to $910bn in 2031, from 7% to 12% of the federal budget, totalling $5.4trn over 10 years — making it the fastest growing component of the federal budget — and 45% of the federal budget in 2050 ($60trn, 9% of GDP). That’s far higher than the previous postwar peak of 19%.
➤ After more than a year of rising interest rates, at the start of 2023 the percentage change in the M2 money supply declined absolutely for the first time since the end of 1932, during ‘the Great Depression’ — from a greater relative ‘height’ and at a greater relative ‘steepness’.
From March 2021 to June 2023, the rate of M2 growth fell by 31% from its peak of 26.3%, contributing to disinflation (slowing inflation) of about 5%; compared to 12% and 10.5% actual deflation in 1932.
➤ The Fed itself started to operate at a loss in October 2022 — with its long-term assets fixed at lower rates but its short-term liabilities (money owed) burdened by rising interest rates — putting it on course to have negative tangible equity (liabilities exceeding assets) for the first time.
That meant the Treasury stopped receiving the Fed’s surpluses, a $100bn+ annual revenue source — four times the annual budget of NASA.
➤ It took eight years of interest rate hikes peaking at 19% in 1981 to bring down the inflation of the 1970s — lower wages relative to rising household debt levels mean interest rates of 3% in Britain in 2022 were the equivalent of 14% in 1980.
In 2019, after interest rates had crept back up from 0% over 30 months to 2.5%, the highest since early 2008, the US yield curve inverted for the first time since before the GFC.
(That is, the demand for and yield (interest/return/profit) on 10-year government bonds went lower than 2-year bonds; suggesting that the market as a whole is becoming more pessimistic about economic prospects for the near future.)
Remarkably, however, the inversion struck after the baseline interest rate had moved back down (from 2.25% to 2% at the end of July).
The remarkable kept coming: while falling share and rising bond prices in a crisis usually generate falling interest rates, on 9 March 2020 the 10-year US Treasury Bond interest rate spiked upwards — something that, according to one bond trader, statistically speaking should only happen every few millennia.
In 2022 the 10-year/3-month yield curve inversion hit the same level as in 1928 (the year preceding the Wall Street Crash which triggered the Great Depression).
➤ In October 2022 the US’s Strategic Petroleum Reserve fell to a 38-year low of 21 days of domestic demand, down from 40 in 2020. The 283 million barrels sold in 2021–2 took 25 years to accumulate. The US’s diesel reserve supply also fell to a historically low 25 days.
In August 2023, the credit rating agency Fitch downgraded the US’s credit rating, which investors use as a benchmark for judging how risky it is to lend money to a government, from AAA to AA+.
The economic necessity of socialism
➤ Since private enterprise is increasingly dependent on monopolisation and long-term central planning (eliminated internal markets, centralised databases, real-time stock analysis, etc.) and state (public) subsidies (including tax cuts) — trending towards 100% of income and therefore nationalisation — taking the means of production under public ownership, a ‘final merger’, and centrally planning the economy as a whole, is becoming, for the first time, an economic necessity.
➤ Since the private sector is losing its ability to employ value-creating (commodity-producing) labour — it does so only if profitable — society, via the state and state enterprises, must take over responsibility for employment, enabling actual full formal employment. (‘Full employment’ in capitalism discounts lumpenised/destitute ‘economically inactive’ workers.)
➤ Since the workforce is now almost entirely services-based, economic stability can only be established by an applicable system, whereby value is created not by for-profit commodity-production but by break-even utility-production.
➤ Since fiat currency is dying a natural death, with cash also disappearing in relative terms — only so much cash can be stored physically; accumulation demands increasing efficiency in circulation and turnover; and cash must be converted into bonds to lower interest rates — it must be replaced by a non-transferable digital voucher system, with the ‘currency’ pegged to labour time.
Workers will therefore receive all the value they create during the working day (instead of having part of it appropriated by capitalists both at the point of production and in the form of public subsidies), paid in units of labour time worked, minus contributions to universal public services and other state expenses.
A grading system will incentivise types of work (night shifts, for example) and productivity rates. Prices will tend to fall to zero, rising only with falling demand or in extreme circumstances (such as invasions from any remaining capitalist regimes).
Combined with public ownership and full employment, this system will institutionalise equality of labour, underpinning equal rights (whereas rights under capitalism only really exist to the degree that you have money) and limiting economic inequality to a minimum; while consistently raising living standards for all (especially via general falling prices).
And since digital vouchers will be non-transferable, cancelled like train tickets once ‘spent’, the centralisation of wealth into the hands of a few becomes impossible.
➤ In the long run, as artificial intelligence, 3D-printing, lab-grown food, etc. become increasingly diffuse, localised, and personalised, the divide between producer and consumer will increasingly disappear, bringing about increasing economic independence and abundant (extremely plentiful) material wealth for all, meaning class and the state will become increasingly irrelevant; and both will therefore (continue to) wither away.
So, whereas capitalism has a long-term tendency to centralise wealth and power, socialism has a long-term tendency to decentralise wealth and power.
Essentially and historically, socialism completes what capitalism started but could not finish.
➤ Precision fermentation, 3D-printing, bioplastics, microbial fuel cells, etc., are forms of additive manufacturing — growing, replicating and layering — as opposed to subtractive manufacturing — metal or trees subtracted and shaped from mines or land, for example. So:
(Polluting, non-reciprocal) subtractive and mechanised production = limited/scarce production = capitalism
(Clean, reciprocal) additive and automated production = unlimited/abundant production = communism
- Bastani, A., Fully Automated Luxury Communism, p. 123.
- See Phillips L., Rozworski, M., People’s Republic of Walmart: How the World’s Largest Corporations are Laying the Foundation for Socialism, Verso, 2019.
“While [Walmart] operates within the [international] market, internally … everything is planned… The different departments, stores, trucks and suppliers do not compete against each other in a market; everything is coordinated… (p. 21)…. It is no small irony that one of Walmart’s main competitors… Sears, Roebuck & Company, destroyed itself by … instituting an internal market (pp. 27–31).”
Ted Reese is the author of: Socialism or Extinction: Climate, Automation and War in the Final Capitalist Breakdown | Humanising Production: The Second (Not Fourth) Industrial Revolution and The Bio-Economic Necessity of Socialism | The End of Capitalism: The Thought of Henryk Grossman
Free PDFs: linktr.ee/grossmanite